Many people turn to the phrase everything happens for a reason when life falls apart. It sounds reassuring, and it suggests that suffering fits into a bigger plan.
However, comfort can quickly turn into harm. When spoken to someone who is grieving, this phrase can feel dismissive. It can minimize pain. It can imply that God caused suffering on purpose.
As a result, people begin asking the wrong questions and start to wonder what they did wrong. They search for hidden lessons. They assume blame. Instead of healing, they carry guilt.
Where This Idea Comes From
The belief behind everything happens for a reason often connects to the idea that God controls every detail of life. Some theological traditions taught that God orchestrates all events, even tragedy. Over time, this belief shaped how Christians talked about suffering.
Yet this way of thinking raises serious questions. Did God cause trauma to teach a lesson? Did God plan loss to bring future joy? Those conclusions don’t reflect the God revealed in Jesus.
Some things happen because the world is broken. Others happen because people misuse free will. Evil exists. Suffering exists. Not everything aligns with God’s desire for humanity.
Why This Phrase Can Deepen Pain
People often use everything happens for a reason during moments of deep loss. Unfortunately, the phrase can make grief heavier. It pressures people to find meaning before they’re ready. It can suggest that pain serves a purpose God intended.
Counselors hear this all the time. People assume suffering equals punishment. They search their past for mistakes. They internalize shame. Instead of feeling supported, they feel judged by God and by others.
Meaning doesn’t heal pain on demand. Presence does.
What Scripture Actually Says
Many people point to Romans 8:28 to support this phrase. However, Paul does not say God causes everything. He says God works within everything. God redeems suffering. God does not design it.
Paul describes a God who groans with creation. He speaks of a Spirit who intercedes when words fail. He proclaims a love nothing can separate us from. That is different from claiming every tragedy has a reason.
God does not control pain. God accompanies us through it.
Jesus Rejects Simple Explanations
Jesus consistently pushed back against linking suffering to reason. When His disciples asked who sinned to cause a man’s blindness, Jesus refused the premise. He shifted the focus away from blame and toward compassion.
Throughout the Gospels, Jesus acts. He heals, and He feeds. He even confronts injustice. Jesus never tells people to accept suffering as “meant to be.” He enters it and transforms it through love.
Even on the cross, Jesus cries out in anguish. He doesn’t explain His pain. He names it.
A Better Way Forward
Instead of saying everything happens for a reason, we can choose better words. We can say, “I’m sorry”… and “I’m here.” We can sit in the darkness without rushing to fix it.
God does not stand above suffering pulling strings. God stands beside us, offering presence, comfort, and hope. That truth doesn’t explain pain—but it makes survival possible.
And sometimes, that is enough.
Comments are closed